Quick answer: A luxury watch can occasionally act as an alternative asset that holds or gains value, but most watches are not investments. They are illiquid, costly to buy and sell, expensive to authenticate and service, and only a narrow set of models from a few brands have historically appreciated. Treat a watch as something you enjoy first, and any resale value as a bonus, not a plan.
Prefer the app?Watch on YouTube
By Jake Claver. Educational content, not investment advice.
The title is deliberately bold. Jake’s video uses luxury watches to talk about networking and status, not a guaranteed payout. This companion page separates the collectible-asset reality from the get-rich framing, so you can judge the idea honestly.
Watches as an alternative asset
Collectibles such as watches, art, and coins sit in the broad category of alternative investments, alongside things like private funds and commodities. The SEC’s overview of investment products groups alternatives together for a reason: they tend to be less liquid, harder to value, and less regulated than stocks or bonds. A watch is a physical object with a resale market, not a security that pays dividends or interest. Its value depends on demand from other collectors, which can rise and fall with fashion.
The costs the headline skips
Buying and selling watches is expensive. Dealer margins, auction fees, insurance, and periodic servicing all eat into any gain. Authentication is a real hurdle: counterfeits are sophisticated, and a watch without documented provenance can be difficult to sell at full value. Unlike a brokerage account, there is no instant, low-cost exit. If you need cash quickly, you may accept well below what the piece is theoretically worth. Illiquidity is the defining feature, not a footnote.
Most watches lose value
The stories that circulate involve a small number of steel sports models from a handful of brands that saw strong secondary demand. The large majority of watches, including many expensive ones, sell used for less than their retail price. Survivorship bias makes the category look better than it is: the winners get written about, the ones that depreciated do not. Assuming your watch is the exception is how the “investment” framing goes wrong.
Taxes and the fine print
If a collectible does appreciate and you sell it at a profit, the tax treatment differs from ordinary stocks. The IRS treats gains on collectibles differently: per IRS Topic 409 on capital gains, net gains from selling collectibles can be taxed at a maximum 28% rate, higher than the top long-term rate for many other assets. That is one more reason to keep expectations grounded.
Why this matters
Framing a luxury purchase as an investment can justify spending money you would not otherwise spend. The more honest version of Jake’s point is about access: a fine watch can be a conversation starter and a signal within certain circles, which has social value. That is different from a financial return. And any market where prices depend on hype and hard-to-verify authenticity is a market where fraud and misrepresentation show up, so caution matters.
Common questions
Can a watch really make you a millionaire?
It is extremely rare. A few models from top brands have appreciated sharply, but the vast majority of watches sell used for less than retail. Treating a single watch as a wealth strategy is not realistic.
Are luxury watches a good investment?
For most people, no. Watches are illiquid, carry high transaction and servicing costs, and require authentication. They are better understood as collectibles you enjoy, with any resale value as a secondary benefit.
What are the biggest risks with watches as assets?
Illiquidity, high buying and selling costs, counterfeits and provenance problems, shifting collector demand, and the tax treatment of collectible gains. Prices can also fall when a trend cools.
How are gains on collectible watches taxed?
In the United States, net gains from selling collectibles can be taxed at a maximum 28% rate under IRS rules, which is higher than the top long-term capital gains rate that applies to many other assets. Confirm your situation with a tax professional.
This content is educational only. It is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Check primary sources and speak with a qualified professional before making financial decisions.
Part of our guide: Crypto Taxes.
